Loading the scorecard…
Loading the scorecard…
Does unusual betting before the news actually know something? Here is every finished case Foreshadow has scored, 1,657 so far, grouped by how unusual the betting was. Nothing is picked by hand, and the numbers update as new cases finish. FDA cases go back a year; earnings cases cover the last few months, and a full year for some of the largest companies.
FDA
Before FDA news, when the betting leaned one way, unusual betting was right 26% of the time (6 of 23), about 3.5 times as often as ordinary betting (7%). The edge is in the size of the move: the stock moved more than options expected 27% of the time, against 14%. Which way it moved was close to a coin flip (61% the way the bets leaned).
Tested apart, so the mix of news can't explain it
Decisions and trial readouts (183 cases): Before FDA decisions and trial readouts, when the betting leaned one way, unusual betting was right 38% of the time (5 of 13), about 4.5 times as often as ordinary betting (9%). That's only 13 cases, so treat it as early.
Routine updates (404 cases): Before routine FDA updates, unusual betting hasn't clearly beaten ordinary betting so far: 10% right against 7%, counting cases where the bets leaned. That's only 10 cases, so treat it as early.
Earnings
Before earnings, unusual betting hasn't clearly beaten ordinary betting so far: 15% right against 14%, counting cases where the bets leaned.
The bets count as right when the stock moved at least as much as options traders expected, in the direction the bets leaned. That is a high bar: options prices already include the expected move, so most bets miss it. Cases where the bets didn't lean either way can't be right, so they are left out of this rate.
Why most cases aren't “right”: across all 1,657 cases, the stock beat its expected move only 25% of the time, in either direction. Pick a direction at random and you'd be right about half of that, roughly 13% of the time. That's the yardstick; on case pages, “Right way” marks the cases that moved the way the bets leaned but by less than expected.
The cases behind the numbers: betting scored 40 or more, and the stock then moved more than expected in the direction the bets leaned. Biggest moves first.
Two looser checks sit beside “right”: whether the stock moved more than expected in either direction, and whether it moved the way the bets leaned at all.
| News | Score | Cases | Bets right | Moved more than expected | Moved the way bets leaned |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FDA | 0 to 19 | 409 | 7% | 14% | 57% |
| FDA | 20 to 39 | 148 | 9% | 16% | 51% |
| FDA | 40 to 69 | 30 | 26% | 27% | 61% |
| FDA | 70 and up | 0 | — | — | — |
| Earnings | 0 to 19 | 699 | 14% | 30% |
Short answers from every finished case and Unusual Whales, written by Claude.
Think you can read the bets better? Play Guess the move: five real cases, the result hidden.
The “ordinary” row shows how often bets turn out right when nothing unusual happened. Unusual betting only means something if it beats that.
Who placed the bets or why. A good record can come from skill, research or luck, and none of it is advice about what to trade.
Every number here comes from the cases in Past cases, each with its trades, its score's arithmetic and what the stock did.
Bars share one scale, 0 to 30%. Rows marked “few cases” have under 10: too few to read much into.
| 49% |
| Earnings | 20 to 39 | 323 | 12% | 31% | 46% |
| Earnings | 40 to 69 | 47 | 16% | 32% | 45% |
| Earnings | 70 and up | 1 | 0% | 0% | 100% |